What brand review is checking
Every check traces to a document. If a check can’t be traced to one, it isn’t a brand check.The AI pre-review
Because every check traces to a document, a builder can run the whole table before a human reviewer sees the work: pass or fail per check, with the document and rule cited, plus every deliberate deviation the producer flagged. Work then arrives at the reviewer with the brief, the shipping version, and the findings attached, which is what makes one round the normal outcome. The two checks that stay a person’s read are “does it sound like us” and whether the imagery genuinely matches; the reviewer rules on those and issues the outcome.What a reviewer may not reject work for
This half matters as much as the first. Without it, brand review becomes an unbounded taste veto and briefs stop meaning anything.- Personal preference about a layout, a photo, or a turn of phrase.
- A change of mind about the strategy after the brief was approved.
- Anything not written in one of the six documents above.
- Something the brief explicitly permitted.
- The work having been drafted by an AI. These rules bind regardless of who or what produced the work; the checks are the checks.
When work needs brand review
Approve the thing that is new. Re-reviewing production work that reuses cleared material is the main reason review queues back up.
Getting through in one round
1
Run the creative review checklist first
The creative review checklist covers most of what brand review will look at. Most rejections are things the producer could have caught.
2
Submit the version that will actually ship
Including every crop and placement. An asset approved at master size and rejected at square costs a whole round.
3
Name the brief
Review is against a brief. Work submitted without one gets reviewed against the reviewer’s assumptions instead.
4
Flag anything you knowingly bent
A deliberate exception with a reason attached usually gets approved. The same exception discovered by the reviewer reads as a mistake. An AI producer attaches its deviations list by default; a human producer writes theirs down.
The outcome
Brand review returns one of three things, and the middle one is the most useful:- Approved. Record the version and date on the brief.
- Approved with conditions. Named, specific fixes; no second review needed once they’re made.
- Rejected. Cite the document and the rule. A rejection without a citation is a preference.
Related resources
- Approval process Approvers, order, turnaround, and escalation.
- Legal review process The parallel review, checking different things.
- Creative review checklist The pass before submitting.
- Brand guidelines The index to all six documents review checks against.
- Brand onboarding What to read before producing brand-facing work.
MCP wiring
MCP wiring
Type: process
Domains: brand, approval
Provides:
Uses:
Hands off to:
Domains: brand, approval
Provides:
process:brand-approvalUses:
approval-route, approved-claims, brand-assets, brand-voice, checklist-review, logo-usage, messaging, positioning, visual-identityHands off to:
process:approvalTriggers: “Is this on brand?” · “Run brand review on this” · “Pre-check before I send to the brand lead” · “Why was this rejected?”Asks, in order:- Which brief is this produced against? Options:
creative-brief. Skip when: attached or linked. - Anything you deliberately bent from the rules, and why? Options: your answer.
Get the complete Marketing OS
Subscribe to Snow Doughnut, our free weekly newsletter, and get the Notion workspace where you do the work: tasks, a marketing calendar, name generators, briefs, and more.
Have us run it for you
We implement this system, use it to help you grow and scale, then hand it all off to you when you’re ready.