Skip to main content
Get this template as a Google Doc: make a copy.
Use this when a piece of creative comes back and someone has to approve it. Review against what the brief asked for. Taste is not a review criterion, and “I’d have done it differently” is not a revision request.
This is step 7 of the creative brief process. It assumes a filled creative brief exists. If there’s no brief, there’s nothing to review against, and that’s the first thing to fix.

Against the brief

  • The asset does the job the brief’s objective names.
  • It carries the one message the brief specified, not a nearby one.
  • The proof point the brief required is visible or audible, not implied.
  • It speaks to the customer profile the brief named, from the library.
  • Every mandatory element in the brief is present.
  • Nothing on the brief’s “must not appear” list is present.

Brand

  • Colors are from the palette in visual identity, at the values recorded there.
  • Type is set in the brand typefaces, at a size on the type scale.
  • Text over image meets the contrast pairings in visual identity. Check the worst spot, not the average.
  • The logo is a correct variant for its background, per logo usage.
  • Clear space around the logo is respected, and the logo is above minimum size at the smallest placement it will appear in.
  • Nothing on the misuse list has been done to the logo, including a retyped wordmark.
  • Imagery matches the direction in visual identity, including what that section says to avoid.

Copy on the asset

  • Voice matches the relevant section of brand voice and tone.
  • Every claim appears in the approved claims table in messaging.
  • Any number, comparison, or superlative has cleared legal review.
  • The call to action states the action, not a mood.

Specs and formats

  • Every deliverable the brief listed has been supplied, not just the hero format.
  • Dimensions, aspect ratios, and file sizes meet the platform spec: Meta, Google, LinkedIn, TikTok, email, or the shared image and video specs.
  • Safe zones are respected. Check the crop that will actually run, not the master.
  • Video has captions, and works with sound off.
  • Images have alt text written.
Check the smallest and most cropped placement before approving. An asset that reads well at full size and loses its logo or its text in a square crop is not approved creative, it’s a master file that still needs work.

Before approval

Giving feedback

  • Each revision request cites the brief line it comes from.
  • Requests are batched into one round, not sent as they occur to people.
  • Anything that isn’t in the brief but genuinely matters gets added to the brief first, so the change is visible rather than remembered.
Type: checklist
Domains: creative, brand, approval
Provides: checklist-review
Uses: approved-claims, asset-locations, brand-assets, brand-voice, creative-best-practices, creative-brief, creative-specs, customer-profile, legal-triggers, logo-usage, naming-convention, visual-identity
Hands off to: process:brand-approval, process:legal-review
Asks, in order:
  1. Which brief commissioned this? Options: creative-brief. Skip when: linked.
  2. Attach every format/crop that will run. Options: your answer. Skip when: all deliverables attached.
Output: Findings per section (brief, brand, copy on asset, specs, before-approval), feedback batched into one round with each note citing a brief line.

Get the complete Marketing OS

Subscribe to Snow Doughnut, our free weekly newsletter, and get the Notion workspace where you do the work: tasks, a marketing calendar, name generators, briefs, and more.

Have us run it for you

We implement this system, use it to help you grow and scale, then hand it all off to you when you’re ready.
Last modified on November 2, 2026