Check what decayed
- The “what will go out of date first” note from the original brief still holds, or has already happened.
- Every statistic, price, spec, and screenshot is still accurate.
- Product and feature names still match what we call them now.
- Organic traffic and rankings for the article’s main queries have not slipped.
- Running the article’s primary question as a prompt in the AI tools our customers use still returns us, not only a competitor.
- Nobody has published a more current or more complete answer since the last review.
- People are still asking this question, and asking it the same way.
- Outbound links still work. Inbound links from the brief still exist.
Decide
One of four, and record which:
Leaving an article alone is a decision, not a skipped step. Record it so the next reviewer knows it was checked.
If updating
- The change is substantive: new data, a new section, a removed section, corrected facts, or a rewritten opening. Not a date bump.
- New statistics carry their source and year.
- Sources for existing statistics still say what the article claims they say.
- The opening still answers the primary question directly.
- Internal links added to articles published since the last review.
- Any new section follows the same structure rules: answers its heading first, then expands.
- Heading structure is still sound after the edits, with one H1 and no skipped levels.
- Meta description still describes what the article now says.
If consolidating or retiring
- The strongest version is chosen as the survivor, and the rest merge into it.
- Anything worth keeping from the retired articles has been moved across before removal.
- A 301 redirect points each removed URL to the closest equivalent page, not the homepage.
- Internal links pointing at the removed URLs are updated.
- The register row is marked, not deleted.
Close it out
- Last-updated date changed on the page, and it reflects a real change.
- Last-updated date changed in the register.
- Next review date set, per the cadence for the tier.
- Status updated if it changed: live, consolidated, retired, or frozen.
- One-line note in the register saying what changed, so the next review starts fast.
Related resources
- Article maintenance process The cycle this checklist runs inside.
- Hero article register and supporting article register
- Article standards The cadence defaults.
- Article process For an article that needs rewriting rather than updating.