Skip to main content
Get this template as a Google Doc: make a copy.
Run this on each article pulled from the register during the maintenance cycle. It is deliberately shorter than the pre-publish checklist, because a review that takes as long as writing the article will not happen on schedule.

Check what decayed

  • The “what will go out of date first” note from the original brief still holds, or has already happened.
  • Every statistic, price, spec, and screenshot is still accurate.
  • Product and feature names still match what we call them now.
  • Organic traffic and rankings for the article’s main queries have not slipped.
  • Running the article’s primary question as a prompt in the AI tools our customers use still returns us, not only a competitor.
  • Nobody has published a more current or more complete answer since the last review.
  • People are still asking this question, and asking it the same way.
  • Outbound links still work. Inbound links from the brief still exist.

Decide

One of four, and record which: Leaving an article alone is a decision, not a skipped step. Record it so the next reviewer knows it was checked.

If updating

  • The change is substantive: new data, a new section, a removed section, corrected facts, or a rewritten opening. Not a date bump.
  • New statistics carry their source and year.
  • Sources for existing statistics still say what the article claims they say.
  • The opening still answers the primary question directly.
  • Internal links added to articles published since the last review.
  • Any new section follows the same structure rules: answers its heading first, then expands.
  • Heading structure is still sound after the edits, with one H1 and no skipped levels.
  • Meta description still describes what the article now says.

If consolidating or retiring

  • The strongest version is chosen as the survivor, and the rest merge into it.
  • Anything worth keeping from the retired articles has been moved across before removal.
  • A 301 redirect points each removed URL to the closest equivalent page, not the homepage.
  • Internal links pointing at the removed URLs are updated.
  • The register row is marked, not deleted.
A removed page with no redirect loses every inbound link and citation pointing at it, including the ones nobody knew about. Redirect first, remove second.

Close it out

  • The change is recorded in the register.
  • Next review date set, per the cadence for the tier.
  • Status updated if it changed: live, consolidated, retired, or frozen.
  • One-line note in the register saying what changed, so the next review starts fast.
Type: checklist
Domains: content
Provides: checklist-review:article-update
Uses: article-brief, article-standards, library:article
Hands off to: process:article
Asks, in order:
  1. Update, consolidate, retire, or leave? Options: article-update-decision. Skip when: never skip; offer recommendation from decay checks.
Output: Decay findings, recorded decision, edits or redirects plan, register updated with next review date and one-line note.

Get the complete Marketing OS

Subscribe to Snow Doughnut, our free weekly newsletter, and get the Notion workspace where you do the work: tasks, a marketing calendar, name generators, briefs, and more.

Have us run it for you

We implement this system, use it to help you grow and scale, then hand it all off to you when you’re ready.
Last modified on November 2, 2026